• Home: Leading Financial Advisor Recruiting Firm
  • About Us
    • Meet the Team
    • Testimonials
    • Case Studies
    • Representative Deals
  • Services
    • For Financial Advisors
    • For Independent Business Owners
  • FAQs
  • Articles
  • Podcast
    • Industry Update
    • Independence 101 Series
  • In the News
    • Moves in the News
  • Tools for Advisors
    • Diamond Consultants Advisor Transition Report 2022
    • NEW – Edward Jones Advisor Transition Report 2022 edition
    • Merrill Information Hub
    • UBS Information Hub
  • Contact Us
  • Subscribe for Updates

Questions? Call us: 908-879-1002

Contact us...
Diamond Consultants: Financial Advisor Recruiting FirmDiamond Consultants: Financial Advisor Recruiting Firm
  • Home
  • About
    • Meet the Team
      • Mindy Diamond
      • Louis Diamond
      • Howard Diamond
      • Jason Diamond
      • Barbara Herman
      • Deborah Aronson
      • Wendy Leung
      • Cathy Nichols
      • Debbie Wallen
      • Allison Brunwasser
      • Joshua Tomolak
      • Shelley Muzio
      • Caryl Felicetta
      • Donna Riopel
      • Kelly Griffiths
    • Testimonials
    • Case Studies
    • Representative Deals
  • Services
    • For Financial Advisors
    • For Independent Business Owners
      • Sell-Side M&A Advisory
      • Consulting
  • FAQs
  • Articles
    • Subscribe for Updates
  • Podcast
    • Industry Update
    • Independence 101 Series
    • Subscribe for Updates
  • In the News
    • Moves in the News
    • Transition Announcements
  • Tools For Advisors
    • NEW – Diamond Consultants Advisor Transition Report 2022
    • NEW – Edward Jones Advisor Transition Report 2022 edition
    • Merrill Information Hub
    • UBS Information Hub
    • Other Tools
    • Subscribe to e-Newsletter

“Should I stay or should I go?”

“Should I stay or should I go?”

“Should I stay or should I go?”

Posted by Mindy Diamond

I’m betting that “Should I Stay or Should I Go,” the 1982 song by The Clash, has come to mind for every Barclays advisor in the past several months. Their roller coaster ride of not knowing what firm they would be working for ended earlier in June when Stifel Nicolaus announced their intent to acquire Barclays’ 180+ advisor wealth management unit. This acquisition is just the latest in the ever-changing landscape of the financial services industry. Whether it’s Stifel’s purchase of Sterne Agee earlier this year, the acquisition of Morgan Keegan by Raymond James in 2012, or Bank of America‘s acquisition of Merrill Lynch in 2008, financial advisors working for the newly acquired firms are typically faced with uncertainty after the initial relief wears off. With third-party recruiters and managers from competing firms circling highly productive advisors like vultures, dangling uber-aggressive transition packages, the FAs that hadn’t jumped ship earlier are often left to weigh the retention package offered by the acquiring firm (e.g., Stifel’s offer is approx. 150% of trailing 12 month’s production) against typically much larger bonuses if they move to another firm.

Is it only about the economics?

How does an advisor decide between accepting a retention package from his own firm or a transition package from a competitor? The calculus is actually not dissimilar to the exercise every advisor should go through periodically—assessing the current state of affairs: “Is my firm giving me everything I need in order to achieve my goals? Where do I see myself over the next 5-10 years? What do I want to be when I grow up?” The only difference for an advisor working for a firm that is being acquired with a retention package awaiting him if he pledges loyalty is that 150% of trailing 12 is a lot of money to be paid for essentially staying the course. Accepting the retention package poses much less risk than changing firms because you save yourself the trouble of having to re-solicit your clients, and it is a heckuva lot easier than disrupting your life for a few months as you settle into a whole new world. Bottom line: If you were happy enough at your firm before the acquisition was announced and your intent was to stay put, then that 150% windfall is essentially found money. But, if there were frustrations you were dealing with that were impacting your ability to service clients, grow your business, and/or your professional quality of life, then even a 500% retention package won’t necessarily make your life any better.

Some additional questions advisors working for firms that experience a change in ownership need to ask themselves:

  1. Will things stay the same? Will the acquiring firm make changes that will force me to work differently than I am used to or want to?
  2. Will local and regional management stay the same? Who will I be reporting to?
  3. Will advisor compensation change?
  4. For how long am I tying myself up? By accepting a retention package, what is expected of me?
  5. Have I evaluated other options? Do I know what I am worth elsewhere? Is there an option that might allow me to service clients and grow my business in a better and more efficient way?
  6. Culturally, will becoming part of a larger organization change things? How will that feel?
  7. Will my old firm’s name be retained permanently? If not, will the new name resonate with my clients and prospects?

Although these are questions all advisors should be asking themselves, an advisor whose firm is being acquired has the perfect excuse to go through this self-reflection exercise. While the process may seem daunting, and the assumption is that there is no perfect solution, still being armed with the answers to questions, an advisor will be on his way to answering the question dogging him: “Should I stay or should I go?”

You may also be interested in...

Share
0

About Mindy Diamond

CEO – By counseling advisors on how to ask the right questions and “dig deep”, she helps them look at all of the opportunities available to find the one that allows them to reach their full potential. That is, to best serve their clients and live a life that is in sync with their own beliefs and values. Learn more...

    Subscribe for Updates

    Get updated by email when a new article is added.


    Listen. Here. Now

    Recent News & Articles

    • From Cold-Calling to $500mm Breakaway: A Former Merrill Advisor’s Team-Based Approach to Growth
    • As Wealth Managers Move To Diversify Customers’ Idle Cash, SVB’s Own Advisors Head For Exits
    • Soul-searching wealth advisors ponder banking turmoil: Where do I want to work?
    • Financing Independence: A Lender’s Perspective on Breakaway Transitions, M&A and Succession
    • Winners and Losers: The Year that Was in the Wealth Management Recruiting Space
    Schedule a Complimentary Consultation
    We're available to answer your questions. Contact us

    Connect with us

    Search

    © 2023 · Diamond Financial Consultants, LLC t/a Diamond Consultants. All rights reserved.*

    • Leading Financial Advisor Recruiting Firm:
    • About
    • Services
    • FAQs
    • Articles
    • Podcast
    • News/Media
    • Tools/Resources
    • Contact
    • Our Locations
    • Privacy Policy
    • Site Map